Monday, July 16, 2012

Wherein We Finally Weigh in on Fifty Shades of Grey




While on vacation recently, I happened to find myself on the verge of a discussion about sex with a family member who was reading Fifty Shades of Grey.  I was lying on a lounge chair in the sun when I overheard my mother-in-law ask my sister-in-law how her book was.  "Oh, it's horrible," she said indignantly.  "It's so filthy."  At the sound of this very loaded word, I opened my eyes, glancing through my sleepy haze and cheap sunglasses in the direction of the conversation.  My sister-in-law held in her hand a copy of the latest literary darling, which also happens to be the latest critical black sheep.




I noticed that my sister-in-law's tone was not one of reticence, of coy refusal to commit, as one might employ when discussing a work of erotic literature with one's own mother.  No, her tone was one of revulsion, conveying the feelings of someone forced to read something against her will.  In a manner of speaking, this was partially true; when asked why she was reading a book that gave her such strong feelings of animosity she said that it was her book club selection, and that she had no choice.

I am a sex blogger, obviously, and as such I presume that I have read more about Fifty Shades of Grey than most of Jill's family, whose exposure to the book might consist solely of reading a review in Entertainment Weekly.  However, I have not read the book itself.  When word of this extremely polarizing tome began to permeate Twitter and the sex blogosphere earlier this year, I visited our local library, just out of curiosity, and found that every copy in the county was checked out, with holds in place on all of them for the next three months.  I eventually managed to get my hands on a copy, and in the hopes of seeing what all the fuss was about, I read one chapter.  However, it took only a couple pages for me to realize that this simply wasn't the right book for me.


Disappointing, really; anything that brings a decidedly kinky practice like BDSM into the mainstream should be a good thing, right?  Perhaps someday an up-and-coming author will write a book that does the same thing for non-monogamy.  Unfortunately, I found author E.L. James' writing style juvenile and unimaginative, with nothing to offer a reader who's already discovered the likes of Tristan Taormino, Rachel Kramer Bussel, Kristina Wright, Allison Tyler, Thomas Roche, and others.



Yes, I can see why Fifty Shades of Grey has captivated the sensibilities of the vanilla mainstream.  It promises the average reader a taste of the taboo, a foray into a forbidden arena they've not yet explored.  I assume that, for the women who are consuming these books so voraciously, BDSM is far too exotic, dark, even dangerous to be a part of their actual sexual repertoire.  The closest women like these come to BDSM is purchasing a pair of pink plastic handcuffs from Spencer's Gifts, using them once, getting a cramp, and then burying them at the bottom of a nightstand drawer.  Let's face it, the average member of the book's target audience isn't a regular BDSM practitioner.  Regular BDSM enthusiasts are probably not going to waste their time reading this book.

Judging by the title and cover alone, Fifty Shades of Grey is a lot less salacious than, say, the typical erotic anthology written by real erotic writers and edited by an individual with a healthy attitude about sex.  The cover features an admittedly artistic and nicely-lit photo of a necktie.  Suggestive, but not too offensive for the delicate sensibilities of the mainstream.  By comparison, the erotic books that hold places of honor in our bookcase have covers that feature (much more artistic) photos of women in corsets, women clasping garter belts to stockings, women performing implied oral sex, and lots of naked people locked in the sort of embraces that don't make the covers of Harlequin-type romance novels.  The title alone is less inflammatory than something like Best Women's Erotica 2012, which might earn you a dirty look as you read it in a public place.



Most importantly - and somehow most perplexingly, even to someone who understands the appeal - Fifty Shades of Grey is tremendously popular, breaking sales records in the U.K. and elsewhere, unseating Harry Potter as the fastest-selling paperback book of all time, and landing its author on Time Magazine's annual list of influential people.  Universal Studios holds the film rights, with Bret Easton Ellis and Angelina Jolie expressing interest in writing and directing, respectively.  That means that even if you're given a dirty look by a conservative type sitting next to you on an airplane as you read it, you can adopt a haughty "Fifty million frustrated housewives can't be wrong" attitude.

Everytime I see a post by one of my Facebook friends - usually a high school or college acquaintance - gushing about how Fifty Shades of Grey is the hottest thing she's ever read, my respect for that individual nosedives a bit.  Make no mistake, I'm always in favor of people reading rather than languishing in front of a television set watching Jersey Shore.  And I certainly have nothing against someone declaring Fifty Shades of Grey a decent time-waster, the sort of throwaway read one might take to the beach, enjoy, and forget about, especially if said someone isn't very sexually adventurous.  But hearing someone declare this book the hottest thing ever makes me want to beg them to read something better, by a writer who's actually been there.

It's worth mentioning that these are the same Facebook friends who regularly line up for the midnight premiere of the latest Twilight movie.  This is especially noteworthy when one considers the fact that Fifty Shades of Grey started life as Twilight fanfiction.  And although no significant resemblance exists between the overrated vampire romance novel series and the overrated BDSM romance novel series, the fact that someone who is sufficiently interested in Twilight to write fan fiction about it under the nom de plume "Snowqueens Icedragon" should be rewarded with a publishing contract is baffling, and not just because I've yet to be rewarded with one myself.


One of the things that has gotten under the skin of most of the BDSM community is the fact that James reportedly had no prior first-hand knowledge of or experience with BDSM, and corresponded with a Dom she'd met online as a way of doing research for the book.  For this, I hesitate to compare James to Vanilla Ice, if only because when the exaggerations of Vanilla Ice's hip-hop qualifications came to light his career fizzled, while no one seems to care that James' BDSM qualifications are spurious.


Technically it shouldn't matter; to my understanding the author has not claimed that Fifty Shades of Grey is a true story, or that her protagonist Anastasia Steele is meant to represent her; James is an author of fiction telling a story that is presented as such.  Whether her research methods consist of first-hand experience, interviews, reference books, or online resources, they should ideally have no bearing on how the book is received provided an entertaining, factually accurate story is told.  This brings me to what has raised the ire of most of the BDSM practitioners who've voiced an opinion on Fifty Shades of Grey.

Christian Grey, the love interest of Anastasia Steele, practices BDSM as a result of deep-rooted childhood trauma.  I can't say whether the author is attempting to claim that the link between psychological damage and interest in BDSM is an across-the-board constant, but if so it clearly betrays her lack of knowledge on the subject.  There is no factual accuracy to the theory that all or even most of those who practice BDSM have such issues; additionally this is an extremely short-sighted sex-negative position that insults not only those who enjoy BDSM, but also those who have suffered a similar trauma.  Actually, the sex-negative aspect might help to explain the book's mainstream popularity.

Additionally, many mainstream literary critics have condemned Fifty Shades of Grey for ostensibly negating feminism, and furthering the false notion that women who submit do so out of a lack of self-respect and the desire to relinquish their free will to a dominant male.  This criticism is ridiculous; those who lack self-respect are unlikely to actively seek out fulfillment of their healthy sexual desires in a consensual fashion.  Perhaps James should not be blamed for how others interpret her work; having failed to complete more than a single chapter I can't reliably say whether or not such an attitude was her intent.

As you can tell, my feelings are strong despite the fact that I only made it through eight or nine pages.  Actually, it might be more accurate to say that my feelings are strong because I only made it through eight or nine pages.  I might have viewed a book written by a more competent author, with better-developed characters and greater substance on offer, more forgivingly than I did this one.  At any rate, it's due to these strong feelings that I wisely opted out of the discussion despite the tractor-beam-like forces drawing me toward it.

I would have gladly discussed the book's pedestrian roots as fan fiction, E.L. James' questionable qualifications to write it, and the book's reputation as an "easy read", a book designed for those who find the typical romance novel too wordy.  I would also have recommended the alternative of Taormino, Bussel, et. al in a heartbeat.  But I wasn't about to get drawn into a debate on the merits of alternative sexual practices lest I inadvertently reveal details about Jill's and my sex life to individuals from whom we've thusfar done a great job hiding them.

I certainly wasn't going to debate the issue with an individual who's recently made it clear - only to Jill and I, presumably not to everyone else in the family - that she thinks I'm a sexist pig, a disrespectful chauvinist, and perhaps if I'm willing to read between the lines not good enough to be married to her sister.  We have long suspected that certain members of our families would judge us if they knew some of our sexual interests - read more about that here - but the revelation that our suspicions have merit kept me lying silently on that lounge chair.













(The above-referenced post can be found here.  Though Molly classifies it as a rant, it's a much more complete and eloquently-stated presentation of the issue than I could ever have written.)

At some point, Jill also noticed the book and asked her sister what she thought of it.  She was given a diatribe on the protagonist's lack of self-respect, followed by the clueless argument that those who practice BDSM are fucked up.  The entire rant - and believe me, that was a rant - was capped by the following argument-winning checkmate:  "It doesn't matter anyway because the book is just disgusting and the only reason I'm reading it is because I have to."  Frankly, I'm disappointed that her main gripe about the book was a negative judgment about its subject matter.  Had her main gripe been "This book is horribly written and whoever gave the author a publishing contract should be fired", I would have been powerless to resist piling on.

To Jill's credit, while she didn't get dragged into the debate - if you can call it that - she did ask her sister why she has to read it.  It's a book club selection, after all, not an English class assignment.

"Well, you have to," she said.  "It's the selection for this month."

"What happens if you just don't read it?  If you feel so strongly about it, refuse on principle."

I believe the discussion died off at this point.

I am always frustrated to learn that intelligent and mature people I respect and care about have bad attitudes about sex.  It shouldn't be surprising, of course; we are conditioned to believe that sex is a necessary evil, something we do for procreation but not for pleasure; or else something that we do for pleasure, but only with strict adherence to conservative guidelines, i.e. behind closed doors; and that daring to talk about it with other adults is akin to urinating in your grandmother's face.  So it doesn't shock or surprise me, but it does make me sad.  Such people could be getting so much more fulfillment out of life if they simply embraced the notion that sex is normal and healthy, and meant to be enjoyed.  Maybe that's the real reason that we don't talk sex with people unless we're certain that they have similar attitudes to ours:  We just don't want to be disappointed.

-Jack

Courtesy of Wordsmoker

Mug o' Monday


Needs a little cream.

-Jill

Sunday, July 15, 2012

Sinful Sunday: In Low Light

I love the way my new corset blends into the shadows.  I love how sultry I feel when I wear it.  I hate how empty this bed is.  Come join me.




See who else is being sinful at Molly's Daily Kiss!

Sinful Sunday

Saturday, July 14, 2012

Daniel and the Rape Joke

When I was in high school, some guest speaker - a psychologist, maybe - told my class that men can't be raped, because men do not have vaginas.  When men are forcibly penetrated, it is - or at the time it was - called sexual assault.  Imagine telling that to a man who's wrapped in a blanket, fearfully and shamefully telling police through sobs and trembles what happened to him.  "Hey, thanks.  It doesn't hurt anywhere near as bad now as it did when I thought it was rape."

We have no open dialogue on rape in this country.  Recently, comedian Daniel Tosh came under fire for a performance in which he said that rape jokes are always funny, and when heckled by an irate member of the audience, said it would be great if she was gang-raped.  When I say "came under fire", what I mean is that he was vilified by sex-positive bloggers and columnists, and then universally defended by his fellow standup comics via Twitter.


I understand the implication:  By muzzling a comedian who dares to resort to material that ventures so far beyond the realm of politically incorrect that it can be termed "inflammatory", "offensive", and "an incitement to violence", we chip further and further away at our collective right to free speech until it is just a momory.  I consider myself a fan of standup comedy, and in the past I've defended the rights of other comedians to say things that I personally found reprehensible.  And I defend Daniel Tosh's right to do the same, even though the tirade in question does nothing to change my opinion of him as a lackluster comedian who somehow got lucky.  Much like Dane Cook.



My favorite performance of his is the one where Kevin Costner kills him.



I may have a problem with Daniel Tosh's image as an obnoxious wannabe frat boy who tries too hard to get laughs, but as a writer I simply cannot fathom a comedian, a writer, a director, a musician, or some other artist being handcuffed by the possibility that someone might commit a crime and blame it on his or her work.  I've loved horror movies all my life, and I hate it when religious conservatives claim that such films are to blame when a heinous crime is committed.  First off, rape and murder existed before movies did.  Second, I watched the same films, and I've never raped or murdered anyone.

I understand that a clearly fictitious piece of entertainment such as a movie, a book, or a video game is much different than a performer seeming to exhort - even in jest - a crowd to visit an act of unspeakable violence and hatred upon another person.  I get that.  And while my opinion on Daniel Tosh's words remains unchanged, I question how what he did is any different than similar outbursts by Michael Richards and Tracy Morgan, both of which resulted in tremendous backlash.

In 2006 Michael Richards screamed racial epithets and threats at an African American heckler ("Fifty years ago we'd have you upside-down with a fucking fork up your ass!").  In 2011, Tracy Morgan said during a performance that he would "pull out a knife and stab" his gay son if he spoke in an effeminate voice.  Acting out of anger, one performer advocates lynching blacks in 1950s America.  The other ostensibly normalizes violence against LGBT individuals, presumably for laughs.  Both comedians were widely ostracized for their words, and both were eventually driven to apologize.


While writing this post this morning, I saw that Tosh has apologized for his remarks.  I'm not a fan of forced apology; telling me that you regret losing your shit and resorting to racial epithets is nowhere near as meaningful as simply not saying it in the first place.  This is doubly true when I consider that such apologies are almost always the result of a consumer or viewer backlash, and not any actual contrition.  Additionally, such an apology allows the audience to give the performer (or the athlete, politician, or other public figure) the benefit of the doubt and continue to enjoy his or her work.  In the eyes of the general public, all is forgiven but nothing actually changes.  Note that while I may be unequivocally in favor of a performer's right to free expression - after all, an incitement to violence doesn't work if the audience isn't already prone to violence - that doesn't mean I'm going to refrain from calling you an asshole after you put your foot in your mouth.


The difference between the Daniel Tosh incident and the Michael Richards and Tracy Morgan incidents lies in the public perception of their hypothetical victims.  If anyone other than Michael Richards thought it was a good idea to stand on a stage and shout the word "nigger" in the presence of an audience, they were either unrepentant white supremacists, or too ashamed of their position to stand with him.  And in the wake of a well-publicized spate of physical and emotional violence against LGBT individuals, there was no chance that Tracy Morgan's comments would be taken as a joke by society at large.

There is no "It Gets Better" project for rape survivors.  Instead, our society trumpets an inexcusable, widespread "blame the victim" policy, and seems far too preoccupied with what a rape victim may have done to make the rapist rape her, or him, than it is with punishing, or even rehabilitating, those who rape.  That a woman may be hesitant to report an incident of sexual violence for fear that she will be judged, belittled, or even penalized for having been a victim is a set of circumstances that I cannot bear.  When someone reports a car theft, the police don't suggest that this is what happens when one owns a nice car.  Likewise, "What were you wearing?" should never be uttered by a detective investigating a rape.

I don't necessarily blame Daniel Tosh, at least not primarily; while it's true that unfunny comedians have no choice but to attempt to shock their audience, I believe that he was influenced the unfeeling reactions of an entitled, male-dominated society that has long stopped pretending to care about the rights of women.  And I don't necessarily blame his audience, who I'm guessing turned against the offended woman in the hopes that Tosh would invite them all backstage after his set.  While their actions may have been insensitive and even cruel, they are to an extent victims of an all too unfortunate misogynistic standard that society - American society at least - seems determined to retain.  But that doesn't make them any less culpable.

When Dharun Ravi was found guilty in the Rutgers University webcam case that led to the suicide of his roommate Tyler Clementi, columnist Dan Savage and other gay rights advocates cited blame-shifting, likened Ravi to a scapegoat, and said that society as a whole was complicit in Clementi's death.  While having a sexual encounter broadcast via webcam - and being forcefully outed at the same time - was a horrible violation, it was likely a lifetime of adversity that drove Clementi to suicide.  The point made by Savage, et. al was that by making an example of Ravi, society could alleviate its own guilt.  To an extent, I get the same sense from Tosh's rape joke.  Yes, he said something that I believe transcends poor taste.  But he was emboldened to do so by a society that apparently considers rape no big deal.

In the wake of the Tracy Morgan incident, Louis CK, a comedian I highly respect, defended Morgan and lamented the fact that by attacking him, LGBT individuals squandered an opportunity to open a dialogue not only on LGBT issues, but also traditional views of masculinity.  He's right; while offended parties are within their rights to voice their opinion of a comedian - or any artist - and his or her material, engaging in a sensible dialogue will benefit society in the long run as it may reshape long-held attitudes in need of changing.  I'm not optimistic, but I hope that Daniel Tosh's rape joke will not result in a squandered  opportunity.

Friday, July 13, 2012

Formspring Friday: Satisfaction



On a scale of 0 to 10, how satisfied are you with your sex life?

We wrote and scheduled this post on July 2nd.  By the time it is published on July 13th, we will have been on a road trip with Jack's parents for almost a week.  We imagine that having them in close quarters for so long will be hell on our sex life, and would probably skew our answer.  Therefore we are opting to write it now, in the comfort of our own home, and in the afterglow of really hot sex.

Rather than posting two separate answers to this question, we discussed it and discovered that our feelings are about the same.  On a scale of 0 to 10, we both consider ourselves about an 8.  Why not a ten?  Well, we are realists.  While it's true that we are very satisfied with our sex life, we know that there is always room for improvement, and we strive constantly to do better.

Also, we can't always have sex as often as we'd like.  Various obligations including work and family interfere with our dreams of having sex twelve hours a day and sleeping the other twelve.  If we could live that kind of life, that would take us up to 9.5 easily.  But we really have little reason to complain.  Our desires are regularly indulged, most of our (reasonable) fantasies are fulfilled, and we have pretty much everything we require to truly be sexually satisfied.

Still, there are always going to be new things we want to try, including toys, positions, locations, and people.  To some extent these things act as motivation, and keep us wanting more.  Thus we remain focused and not complacent.  Sexually, we are always on the move.

Despite the joke I made above, I don't know that anything would really elevate us above an 8.  Our attitudes toward sex mean we're always grounded in reality, and we realize that perfection is hardly ever achievable.

If you want to ask us anything, drop us a line on Formspring, or use the handy Formspring widget on the right-hand side of our blog.  We like sexy questions!  To see who else participated this week, visit Twitter and search for #FormspringFriday!

Flash Fiction Friday: The Main Course

This summary is not available. Please click here to view the post.

Thursday, July 12, 2012

The Naughty Hangout: Pop!

This week's theme at The Naughty Hangout is "Balloons/Balls".  Although Jack was dying to post a picture of his balls, I thought we'd try something different instead.  Since one of the backup themes was "Sharp", I've got a balloon in one hand, and a sewing needle in the other.



Jack says that my nipple qualifies for "Sharp" as well.

Go see who else is being naughty this week!

-Jill

Labels

abnormal (1) Amnesia (1) analysis (1) Are You Ready to Get Fucked? (1) arrogance (1) Art Snobbery (1) article (5) baby (1) bath (2) boasting (1) bondage (2) books (2) Boots (1) breakfast (1) C.H.U.D. (1) Cambria List (2) candlelight (2) candles (2) Cell Phones (1) Christine (2) clown porn (1) Courtney Trouble (2) Creepy Blurred Photo (1) cum (1) CVS (1) dark desires (1) Dark Shadows (1) Darth Vader (1) dinner (1) Dirty Haiku (2) double standard (1) dream (1) drink (1) Duck Bill (1) e[lust] (1) EdenFantasys (1) erotic (6) erotic fiction (4) erotica (10) Ex Pertinacia Victoria (1) extreme (1) fact (31) Family Feud (1) fiction (6) Fisting (2) fitness (2) Flash Fiction Friday (7) food (1) Formspring (4) Formspring Friday (4) Funny (9) G-Spot (2) girl-girl (4) Golden Rule (1) group sex (8) Haiku (1) Hair as Erogenous Zone (1) Halloween (5) Han Solo (1) handcuffs (3) heels (1) HNT (13) holiday (5) Horror Movies (1) hot (4) hot tub (2) Huffington Post (2) humor (3) I Don't Want to Think on a Sunday (1) International Fisting Day (2) Interview (1) kink (2) legs (1) lingerie (2) Louis CK (1) Lynette Burrows (1) manholes (1) Mark Driscoll (1) Mark Ruffalo (1) masturbation (18) Masturbation Month (1) meme (18) Meme Hatred (1) Monday picture (3) Mother's Day (1) motherhood (1) Movie Trailers (1) music (4) My Brain Hurts (1) naked Jack (1) Nintendo Wii (1) nipple (1) nipple play (1) non-fiction (2) non-monogamy (1) non-sex (3) nonfiction (2) normal (1) Not Sexy (5) Obscenity (2) One Million Moms (1) one-on-one (22) opinions (1) oral sex (2) Oz Quote (1) Parenting (1) park (1) Pastor's Wives (1) Petition (1) photo of Jill (6) photography (16) Picasso (1) picture (4) pie (1) playful (1) Poetry (2) Politics (1) Pope Benedict (1) porn (1) Pornography (2) Possible Bullshit (1) Power Exchange (1) Pumpkins (1) Queef (1) rabbit (3) Reality TV (1) reasons to have sex (1) relaxation (1) relaxing (1) religion and sexuality (1) restraint (3) Retro HNT (4) Rick Perry's an Idiot (1) Rite Aid (1) Rob Liefeld sucks (1) rocking chair (2) San Francisco Bay Guardian (1) Self-Hating Masturbation Addict (1) sepia (2) sex club (1) Sex Education (2) sex negative (1) sex positive (2) Sex Toys (1) Sex-negative right-wing idiots (3) sex-positive (1) Sexual Development (1) SFBG Article (1) Shitty Kid (1) short fiction (4) shower (1) shower sex (1) silhouette (1) Sinful Sunday (4) slut (1) slut shaming (1) Social Networking (1) Sperm (1) Spitting vs. Swallowing (1) sponsored post (1) Star Wars (3) Steve Harvey (1) stockings (2) submissive (3) Sunday Stealing (3) Swallow (1) swinging (1) taboos (1) Teachers are not usually pedophiles (1) Teenage Jack (1) teeth (1) The Frisky (1) The Naughty Hangout (4) thumbcuffs (3) TMI (7) TMI Tuesday (6) TNH (4) topless (2) toys (6) tribute (2) trust (3) unusual turn-ons (1) vagina cookies (1) Valsalva Maneuver (1) vibrator (3) vibrators (1) Video Clip (1) video games (1) Vincent Price (1) Violent Crime Report (1) virginity (1) voyeurism (1) voyeurism/exhibitionism (18) Walgreens (1) Wanton Wednesday (4) webcam (4) weekly feature (29) Weight Room (1) weights (1) weird (1) Wii (1) wine (1) word of the day (2) workout (2) Written by Both (13) written by Jack (44) written by Jill (46) Written by Neither (1)